How to Choose the Best Ice Cream Maker

How do you choose the best ice cream maker in 2024? What properties and features should the best ice cream maker have to suit your needs? Read our guide and make an informed choice.

The Best Homemade Ice Cream MakerIce cream is more than just a delightful treat; it’s a symbol of joy, creativity, and indulgence. Whether it’s a hot summer day or a cozy winter evening, the allure of ice cream transcends seasons and age groups. But have you ever considered the joy of making your own ice cream at home? With the right ice cream maker, you can explore a world of flavors, textures, and culinary adventures, all from the comfort of your kitchen.

Choosing the best ice cream maker, however, is not just about picking a machine; it’s about finding a companion for your culinary creativity. From understanding different types and capacities to considering additional features, custom flavors, dietary options, and even the brand and price range, there’s a lot to explore. This comprehensive guide aims to unravel the various aspects of selecting the perfect ice cream maker, tailored to your needs and desires. Whether you’re a novice looking to experiment or a seasoned dessert chef seeking perfection, this guide will help you navigate the exciting journey of homemade ice cream making.

Types of Ice Cream Makers

When choosing the best ice cream maker, consider these three main types:

Rock Salt Ice Cream Makers

Rock Salt Ice Cream Makers are a traditional and hands-on way to make ice cream. They use a mixture of ice and salt to freeze the ice cream mixture. The salt lowers the freezing point of the ice, allowing it to reach a lower temperature without melting. This method offers more control over the texture, allowing for a more customized consistency.

It’s great for those who like to experiment with different quantities and speeds. While generally more affordable, it requires more manual effort and preparation time. Churning can be done by hand or with an electric churner, depending on the model.

Freezer Bowl Ice Cream Makers

Freezer Bowl Ice Cream Makers are a popular choice for home use. These makers use a special liquid between layers of the bowl to freeze the ice cream ingredients. The bowl must be pre-frozen for at least 24 hours before use, so it requires some pre-planning. Once ready, the machine electrically churns the mixture until it reaches a soft-serve consistency.

These models are often available in different sizes to suit various needs and are usually mid-range in price. The convenience of freezer bowl models is less hands-on than rock salt models, but they do require freezer space and forethought to pre-freeze the bowl.

Compressor Ice Cream Makers

Compressor Ice Cream Makers represent the high-end segment of the market and offer the most advanced features.

Compressor Ice Cream Maker for your homeEquipped with a built-in freezer, these machines can bring the ingredients’ temperatures below freezing immediately, allowing for continuous use without any wait time between batches. The fully automated churning process often produces a smoother and more professional texture.

These models may include digital displays, timers, and various settings for different frozen treats, such as gelato or sorbet. While they are more expensive, they offer the most convenience and features. However, they are generally larger and heavier, so storage space should be considered.


Choosing the right type of ice cream maker depends on your preferences, budget, and how often you plan to make ice cream. If you enjoy the process and want a more hands-on experience, a rock salt ice cream maker might be the best choice. If you’re looking for something more convenient but still affordable, a freezer bowl model could be ideal. For those who want a professional experience with all the bells and whistles, a compressor ice cream maker is the way to go.

Understanding the unique features and considerations of each type will help you find the perfect ice cream maker for your needs, allowing you to enjoy the delicious world of home-made ice cream.

How to Choose the Best Ice Cream Maker


The capacity of an ice cream maker refers to the amount of ice cream it can produce in a single batch. It’s an essential factor to consider based on your needs and the number of people you’ll be serving.

  • Small Capacity: These models typically hold less than 1 quart and are suitable for single servings or small families. They are often more compact and easier to store.
  • Medium Capacity: Creating 1-2 quarts of ice cream, medium-sized ice cream makers are ideal for couples or slightly larger gatherings. They offer a good balance between size and output.
  • Large Capacity: For those who love hosting parties or have large families, ice cream makers that hold 2-4 quarts are available. These machines can handle bigger batches but may require more storage space.

Understanding your ice cream-making habits and the number of people you usually serve will help you choose the right capacity for your needs.


Speed refers to how quickly an ice cream maker can churn a batch of ice cream. It varies significantly between different models and types:

  • Rock Salt Models: These can be slower, especially if hand-churned. The process can be a fun activity but may take longer to reach the desired consistency.
  • Freezer Bowl Models: The speed of these models depends on the pre-freezing time of the bowl and the churning time, usually taking several hours in total.
  • Compressor Models: Known for their speed, compressor models can make ice cream almost instantly, with no wait time between batches.

The speed factor is crucial if you plan to make ice cream frequently or need to prepare multiple flavours in a short time.


The texture of the ice cream is influenced by the type of ice cream maker and the method it uses to freeze and churn the mixture:

  • Rock Salt Models: Offer more control over texture, allowing for a customized consistency. You can create anything from soft-serve to a firmer texture.
  • Freezer Bowl Models: These usually churn to a soft-serve consistency, and further firming requires additional freezer time.
  • Compressor Models: Often produce a smoother and more professional texture, replicating the quality of store-bought ice cream.

The texture preference is subjective, and different people may have different expectations. Some may prefer a denser, creamier texture, while others might like a lighter, fluffier consistency.

The capacity, speed, and texture are vital factors to consider when choosing an ice cream maker. They influence not only the quantity and quality of the ice cream but also the overall experience of making it. By understanding these aspects and aligning them with your preferences and needs, you can find the perfect ice cream maker that brings joy to your kitchen and delights to your taste buds. Whether you’re an occasional treat maker or a dedicated dessert chef, there’s an ice cream maker that fits your unique requirements.

Custom Flavours

Owning an ice cream maker opens up a world of creativity and experimentation with flavours.

Homemade ice cream using natural ingredients and flavoursUnlike store-bought ice cream, where you’re limited to available options, homemade ice cream allows you to explore and invent:

  • Experimentation: You can experiment with unique combinations, such as lavender and honey, or basil and lemon. The possibilities are endless, and you can create flavours that suit your palate.
  • Seasonal Ingredients: Utilize fresh, seasonal fruits and herbs to create vibrant and flavourful ice creams that reflect the time of year.
  • Family Fun: Involve family members, especially children, in the process of inventing new flavours. It can be a fun and educational experience.
  • Personal Touch: Add a personal touch to special occasions by creating ice cream that complements the theme or menu of a gathering.

Dietary Options

Home-made ice cream also provides control over the ingredients, making it easier to accommodate various dietary needs and preferences:

  • Vegan Options: By using plant-based milk and sweeteners, you can create delicious vegan ice cream that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture.
  • Low-Calorie Choices: If you’re watching your calorie intake, you can adjust the sugar levels or use alternative sweeteners to create a lighter version.
  • Allergen-Free: For those with allergies or intolerances, home-made ice cream ensures that you know exactly what’s going into your dessert. You can avoid specific allergens and still enjoy a tasty treat.
  • Non-Dairy Alternatives: Experiment with coconut milk, almond milk, or other non-dairy alternatives to create ice creams that cater to lactose intolerance or personal preferences.

The ability to create custom flavours and cater to various dietary options is one of the most rewarding aspects of making ice cream at home. It offers a level of creativity and personalization that’s hard to match with store-bought options. Whether you’re an adventurous foodie looking to explore new flavour combinations or someone who needs to cater to specific dietary needs, an ice cream maker empowers you to craft desserts that are uniquely yours. It’s not just about the end product; it’s about the joy of creation, the satisfaction of customization, and the pleasure of sharing something special with loved ones.

Additional Features

Additional features in an ice cream maker can enhance the overall experience, adding convenience, versatility, and even a touch of luxury to the ice cream-making process.

Here’s a closer look at some of these features:

1. Auto Turn-Off

Some ice cream makers come with an automatic turn-off feature that shuts down the machine once the desired consistency is reached. This is particularly useful if you’re multitasking in the kitchen, as it prevents over-churning and ensures the perfect texture every time.

2. Different Types of Treats

Versatility is a key consideration for many users. Some ice cream makers are designed to create not only ice cream but also other frozen treats like sorbet, gelato, and frozen yogurt. This multi-functionality allows you to explore a wider range of desserts without needing separate appliances.

3. Built-in Freezer

High-end compressor models often come with a built-in freezer, eliminating the need to pre-freeze bowls or prepare ice and salt. This feature adds convenience and speeds up the process, allowing for spontaneous ice cream making whenever the craving strikes.

4. Digital Display and Timers

A digital display with timers and preset functions can make the ice cream-making process more user-friendly. You can easily select different settings, monitor progress, and even set a timer for delayed start, giving you more control and precision.

5. Adjustable Churning Speed

Some models offer adjustable churning speeds, allowing you to control the texture and consistency of your ice cream. Whether you prefer a soft-serve style or a firmer texture, adjustable speeds provide the flexibility to achieve your desired results.

6. Noise Reduction Technology

If you’re concerned about noise, look for models with noise reduction technology. Making ice cream can sometimes be a noisy process, but certain designs and materials can minimize the sound, making the experience more pleasant, especially during late-night cravings.

7. Easy Cleaning

Ease of cleaning is a practical consideration that can significantly impact your enjoyment of the machine. Look for models with detachable parts that are dishwasher safe or easy to rinse, saving you time and effort in cleanup.

8. Aesthetic Design

The design and appearance of the ice cream maker might also be important, especially if it will be a permanent fixture on your kitchen counter. Sleek and stylish designs that match your kitchen décor can add a touch of elegance to your space.

9. Accessories and Recipe Booklets

Some ice cream makers come with additional accessories like extra bowls, paddles, or even recipe booklets. These extras can enhance your ice cream-making experience, providing inspiration and convenience.

Homemade chocolate ice cream using an ice cream makerAdditional features in an ice cream maker can transform a simple appliance into a versatile and enjoyable kitchen tool. From convenience and control to aesthetics and extras, these features cater to various needs and preferences. When choosing an ice cream maker, consider what additional features align with your lifestyle and how you plan to use the machine.

Whether you’re a casual ice cream enthusiast or a dedicated dessert connoisseur, there’s an ice cream maker with features that can elevate your culinary adventures.

Brand and Warranty

Brand Reputation

The brand of an ice cream maker can be a significant indicator of quality and reliability. Established brands often have a track record of producing durable and efficient appliances. They may also offer better customer support and a wider availability of spare parts.


A warranty is a promise from the manufacturer to repair or replace the product if something goes wrong within a specified period. It’s a crucial consideration as it provides peace of mind and protection against defects or malfunctions.

  • Length of Warranty: Look for a warranty that covers a reasonable period, reflecting the manufacturer’s confidence in the product.
  • What’s Covered: Understand what the warranty covers, such as parts, labor, or both, and any specific exclusions.
  • Customer Support: Consider how easy it is to access customer support if you need to claim the warranty. Good customer service can make the process smoother.

Price Range

The price range of ice cream makers varies widely based on features, capacity, type, and brand. Understanding your budget and what you’re willing to invest can help narrow down your options.

  • Budget-Friendly Options: These are often simpler models, such as rock salt or freezer bowl types, suitable for occasional use.
  • Mid-Range Options: These may offer additional features, larger capacity, or more versatility, providing a balance between cost and functionality.
  • High-End Options: Premium models, such as compressor ice cream makers with advanced features, fall into this category. They are often more durable and offer professional-quality results.

User Reviews

User reviews provide real-world insights into how an ice cream maker performs. They can be invaluable in understanding the pros and cons of a particular model.

  • Overall Satisfaction: Look for overall ratings and satisfaction levels. High ratings often indicate a well-received product.
  • Specific Feedback: Read through individual reviews to understand specific likes and dislikes, such as ease of use, noise level, or durability.
  • Expert Opinions: Along with customer reviews, consider expert opinions and recommendations from reputable sources. They often provide detailed analyses and comparisons.


Choosing the perfect ice cream maker is a delightful journey that marries functionality with creativity. It’s about understanding your unique preferences, needs, and culinary aspirations. Whether it’s the joy of crafting custom flavours, the satisfaction of catering to specific dietary needs, or the excitement of exploring additional features, an ice cream maker can be a versatile and rewarding addition to your kitchen. From budget-friendly options to high-end models, there’s a machine designed to fit your lifestyle and unleash your inner dessert chef.

Embarking on the path of home-made ice cream making is more than just a culinary decision; it’s an invitation to a world of creativity, joy, and connection. It’s about sharing special moments with loved ones, experimenting with new ideas, and indulging in the simple pleasure of a well-crafted dessert. With this comprehensive guide, you’re now equipped to make an informed choice that aligns with your dreams and taste buds. May your ice cream maker be the gateway to endless scoops of happiness, one batch at a time. Happy ice cream making!

Recommended Ice Cream Makers

Taking into account the advice above, analysing buyer opinions, and the available offerings, we recommend the following models of Ice Cream Makers that offer excellent value for money.

Recommended Product No. 1
Andrew James Ice Cream Maker Machine Frozen Yoghurt Sorbet Maker, Detachable Ice-Cream Mixing...
4,080 Reviews
Andrew James Ice Cream Maker Machine Frozen Yoghurt Sorbet Maker, Detachable Ice-Cream Mixing...
  • ICE CREAM MAKER MACHINE -- Make delicious ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and frozen yoghurt in your very own kitchen with the Andrew James Ice Cream Maker Machine.
  • FAST HOMEMADE ICE CREAM -- At the touch of a button you can enjoy delectable stress free homemade ice cream in just 20 minutes! Indulge in tangy lemon meringue, smooth peanut butter, or mouth-watering chocolate brownie.
  • REFRESHING FROZEN YOGHURT & SORBET -- Choose this ice cream machine for a fun kitchen activity for your little ones as you can make ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yoghurt that they are sure to love. When you buy an Andrew James Ice Cream Maker you will also receive 3 recipes to get you started on your frozen goodness adventure!
SaleRecommended Product No. 2
KUMIO Ice Cream Maker with Compressor, No Pre-freezing Ice Cream Machine, Gelato Sorbet Frozen...
  • 【No Pre-freezing Ice Cream Maker】The professional compressor system means there is no need to pre-freeze removable bowls, it will be a hassle-free and straightforward process that ensures quick homemade ice cream. Create the delicious dessert of your choice in just one hour. To maintain the frozen state and freshness, the sorbet machine will automatically remain cool for 1 hour without any other operation
  • 【LCD Display Control & Timer】With 4 modes and keep cool function. Built-in manual to guide you on how to use the machine. Just add the ingredients and turn it on. The frozen yogurt machine will show the time and does the rest! A beep sounds to indicate completion. The transparent lid allows you to check the production status of ice cream at any time. Add additional ingredients such as nuts, chocolate chips, fruits, etc
  • 【Easy to Disassemble & Clean & Compact】Featuring a split design with only 4 removable parts and an easy-to-follow instruction manual, you'll be fully installed and running in minutes. The removable lid, ice cream mixing paddle, and bowl make it easy to clean. Measuring only 35.5 X 26.0 X 22.75 cm, the ice cream machine is easy to store and fits on any countertop
SaleRecommended Product No. 3
Ninja CREAMi Ice Cream Maker & Frozen Dessert Maker with 3 Tubs, 7 Programs, Makes Ice Cream,...
  • SO MUCH MORE THAN ICE CREAM: Create & customise delicious homemade treats with 7 Pre Set Programs for Ice Cream,Gelato, Milkshakes, Sorbet, Smoothie Bowls, Light Ice Cream & Mix-Ins
  • FILL, FREEZE, PROCESS, ENJOY: Simply fill a tub with ingredients, pop in the freezer in 24 hours, then process in minutes when you're ready to transform your frozen base into a creamy treat
  • YOUR ICE CREAM, YOUR WAY: Make it indulgent, low sugar, dairy free, vegan and more, to suit every taste, and evenly mix in choc chips, sweets & nuts to complete your treats
SaleRecommended Product No. 4
Lakeland Digital Ice Cream Maker 1.8L – Homemade Ice Cream Sorbet & Frozen Yoghurt In 40 Minutes
  • Makes delicious ice cream, sorbet and frozen yoghurt
  • Ready in as little as 40 minutes
  • Easy-to-read digital display
SaleRecommended Product No. 5
Cuisinart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker | Makes Ice Cream, Gelato, Sorbet, Frozen Yoghurt in 40 Minutes...
  • Makes 1.5L of delicious, homemade ice cream, gelato, frozen yoghurt or sorbet in as little as 40 minutes
  • Professional compressor system means no need to pre-freeze the bowl and no need to wait between batches
  • 2 mixing paddles, one for ice cream and one for gelato to give your recipe the right amount of air for perfect texture
SaleRecommended Product No. 6
Cuisinart Ice Cream Deluxe, Pre-Freeze Ice Cream, Frozen Yoghurt and Sorbet Maker, Silver, ICE30BCU
  • Makes 2L of delicious, homemade ice cream, frozen yoghurt or sorbet in as little as 25 minutes
  • Easy to use. Simply pre-freeze the bowl overnight, add ingredients and switch on
  • Add extra toppings through the lid during churning such as nuts, chocolate chips, fruit pieces and sauces for a ripple effect
SaleRecommended Product No. 7
Cuisinart Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker, White, ICE48U
  • Easily Create Fresh, Homemade Soft Serve Ice Cream And Frozen Treats, In Around 20 Minutes
  • Dispense Soft Serve Ice Cream Directly Into Cones Or Bowls
  • Fully Automatic - Just Prepare A Mixture Of Your Choice Of Ingredients, Pour In And Start Churning
Recommended Product No. 8
Lakeland Mini Digital Ice Cream Maker 0.5L – Homemade Ice Cream In 25 Minutes Plus Sorbet &...
  • Makes ice cream in as little as 25 minutes
  • Small bowl tucks neatly into freezer
  • Great for sorbet and frozen yogurt too

Last update on 2024-06-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      I accept the Privacy Policy