Table of Contents
- 1 Recommended Top Electric Yogurt Makers 2026
- 2 What is an Electric Yogurt Maker and How Does it Work?
- 3 How to Choose the Best Electric Yogurt Maker: A Complete Buying Guide
- 3.1 Capacity and Container Type: Individual Servings or a Family-Sized Batch?
- 3.2 Temperature Control: The Key to Perfect Probiotics
- 3.3 Timers and Automation: Set-and-Forget Convenience
- 3.4 Materials Matter: Glass vs. Plastic Fermentation Jars
- 3.5 Ease of Use and Cleaning: Don’t Let Hassle Spoil the Fun
- 3.6 Versatility: Beyond Plain Yogurt (Greek, Dairy-Free, and More)
- 3.7 Kitchen Footprint: Size and Storage Considerations
- 3.8 Energy Consumption and Running Costs
- 3.9 Build Quality, Warranty, and Brand Reputation
- 3.10 Price vs. Value: Finding the Sweet Spot for Your Budget
- 4 Conclusion
- 5 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s)
- 5.1 1. Can you make Greek yogurt in any electric yogurt maker?
- 5.2 2. Is it cheaper to make your own yogurt with an automatic yogurt machine?
- 5.3 3. What kind of milk is best for a homemade yogurt appliance?
- 5.4 4. Do I need to buy a special starter culture every time?
- 5.5 5. How do I clean my electric yogurt maker and fermentation jars?
- 6 Informative video
Choosing the best electric yogurt maker means finding a machine that matches your specific needs in terms of capacity, temperature controls, and features. For most households, a model with a 1-2 litre capacity, adjustable temperature settings to cultivate different probiotics, an automatic shut-off timer, and dishwasher-safe glass fermentation jars is ideal. This combination offers the perfect balance of convenience, versatility, and long-term value.
Welcome to your complete guide to finding the perfect homemade yogurt appliance. If you’re fed up with inconsistent quality, added sugars, and the ongoing cost of shop-bought yogurts, an electric yogurt maker can be a real game-changer. This simple yet clever device lets you create fresh, delicious, and probiotic-rich yogurt right in your own kitchen with very little effort.
Whether you are health-conscious, a parent wanting nutritious snacks for your family, or a savvy saver looking to cut grocery bills, the right automatic yogurt machine can truly become a kitchen hero. But with so many options available, how do you choose the one that’s really right for you? This guide will take you through every important factor, helping you make a confident and worthwhile purchase.
Recommended Top Electric Yogurt Makers 2026
Using the advice outlined here, along with buyer feedback and available options on the market, we recommend the following models of Electric Yogurt Makers as top picks for cost-effectiveness.
No products found.
What is an Electric Yogurt Maker and How Does it Work?
An electric yogurt maker is a countertop appliance designed to create the perfect environment for fermenting milk into yogurt. Its main function is to keep a mixture of milk and starter culture at a consistent, warm temperature for a set time, usually between 8 and 12 hours.
The process is wonderfully straightforward. You mix milk (dairy or non-dairy) with a small amount of starter culture, which contains live bacteria (the beneficial probiotics). You then pour this mixture into the machine’s containers, set the timer, and let the appliance do its work. The automatic yogurt machine gently heats the mixture and maintains the ideal temperature, allowing the bacteria to multiply, consume the lactose (milk sugar), and produce lactic acid. This thickens the milk and gives yogurt its distinctive tangy flavour.
How to Choose the Best Electric Yogurt Maker: A Complete Buying Guide
Shopping for a homemade yogurt appliance can feel a bit daunting at first. While all promise delicious yogurt, the details really matter. Having helped many people find the kitchen gadgets just right for them, I’ve learnt that the key is to look beyond the adverts and focus on features that suit your lifestyle and yoghurt-making goals. Let’s go through everything you need to consider to find the very best electric yogurt maker for your home.
Capacity and Container Type: Individual Servings or a Family-Sized Batch?
The first question to ask is: how much yoghurt do you and your family typically consume? The capacity of an electric yogurt maker affects how often you’ll need to make new batches and how you’ll store the yoghurt.
Large Single Container Models
An automatic yogurt machine with a single large container, usually between 1 and 2 litres, suits families or individuals who eat a lot of yoghurt. The main benefit is simplicity; you prepare one large batch, and the fermentation tends to be more stable and consistent thanks to the bigger thermal mass. Once it’s ready, you can store the whole container in the fridge and scoop out servings as you go.
This style is also perfect if you want to make Greek yoghurt, as you can pour the entire batch into a strainer easily. The downside is that you’re limited to one flavour per batch. However, if you use plain yoghurt as a base for smoothies, cooking, or with various toppings each day, a large container homemade yogurt appliance is very efficient.
Individual Fermentation Jars
Models with multiple smaller fermentation jars (usually 6 to 8 jars, each around 150-200ml) are fantastic for portion control and flavour variety. You can prepare a week’s worth of grab-and-go breakfast pots in one go. This feature works brilliantly for busy households, packed lunches, or catering to differing family tastes. You could make some plain, some vanilla, and others with fruit puree at the bottom.
Practically, these jars are easy to store in the fridge and serve from directly. The main drawback is that there’s a little more washing up involved. If you go for this style of electric yogurt maker, make sure the lids seal tightly to keep everything fresh.
Temperature Control: The Key to Perfect Probiotics
This is probably the most vital technical feature in any homemade yogurt appliance. The temperature during fermentation affects the final texture, flavour, and, crucially, the health of its probiotic cultures.
Fixed vs. Adjustable Temperature
Basic, budget-friendly models often work at one fixed temperature. This is fine for making standard yoghurt with a regular starter culture. They are easy to use and a good starting point if you’re new to homemade yoghurt.
However, if you’re a keen yoghurt lover or enjoy culinary experiments, an electric yogurt maker with adjustable temperature controls is essential. Different bacterial strains (probiotics) thrive at slightly different temperatures. Being able to adjust this lets you fine-tune conditions for your specific starter, whether it’s a heritage culture that prefers a cooler setting or a thermophilic one that likes it warmer. Adjustable temperature is also important if you want to make dairy-free yoghurt, as almond or coconut milk behaves differently from dairy milk.
The Importance of Consistency
Beyond simply being adjustable, the best automatic yogurt machine will hold its temperature steady with no big fluctuations. Temperature changes can stress the bacteria, causing separated (whey and solids) or sour yoghurt. Look for reviews praising even heating and stable temperatures; these are signs of a quality appliance that delivers reliable results batch after batch.
Timers and Automation: Set-and-Forget Convenience
A built-in timer with an automatic shut-off is a must for modern convenience. Fermentation is time-sensitive. Leaving yoghurt too long can make it overly tangy, sour, and watery. One common beginner mistake is forgetting about yoghurt left to culture, ending up with over-fermented results.
A good electric yogurt maker lets you programme the fermentation time (usually 1 to 24 hours). When time’s up, it automatically stops heating. This prevents over-culturing and gives you a much bigger margin of error. You can run it overnight and wake up to perfectly prepared yoghurt. Some higher-end models even have a ‘chill’ function that cools the yoghurt at the end, which is a lovely extra.
Also, check the display’s clarity. A clear, backlit LCD screen showing remaining time is a small detail but a big help in day-to-day use.
Materials Matter: Glass vs. Plastic Fermentation Jars
The containers that hold your yoghurt are as important as the machine itself. The most common debate is glass versus plastic.
The Case for Glass
From experience, glass is the better option for fermentation jars. It’s non-porous and inert, so it won’t absorb smells or flavours from previous batches, and there’s zero risk of chemicals leaching into your food. Glass also cleans and sterilises easily, which is vital to avoid contamination by unwanted bacteria. Plus, it offers excellent thermal stability, aiding consistent temperature. Its downside is that it’s heavier and more fragile, so you need to be careful.
The Case for Plastic
Plastic jars are lightweight, durable, and won’t shatter if dropped, making them safer in homes with young children. If you choose plastic, ensure the jars are certified BPA-free. BPA is linked to health concerns, and you don’t want it near your wholesome homemade yoghurt. That said, plastic can scratch over time, creating hiding spots for bacteria, and it may also absorb colours or smells.
In the end, while both work, a quality electric yogurt maker with sturdy, well-sealing glass jars is the gold standard for purity and longevity.
Ease of Use and Cleaning: Don’t Let Hassle Spoil the Fun
If your homemade yogurt appliance is tricky to operate or clean, it’ll soon gather dust in the cupboard. Simplicity matters.
Look for an easy-to-use control panel with clearly marked buttons. You shouldn’t need to read the manual every time you want to make a batch. For cleaning, find out if the lid, inner container, or individual fermentation jars are dishwasher-safe—that’s a huge time saver. A machine with a smooth, simple interior and no tricky nooks will be much easier to wipe down.
Versatility: Beyond Plain Yogurt (Greek, Dairy-Free, and More)
A basic electric yogurt maker does one job well. However, many modern models offer more versatility for better long-term value.
Making Greek Yogurt
Greek yoghurt is simply ordinary yoghurt that’s been strained to remove some whey, resulting in a thicker, creamier, higher-protein product. Some automatic yogurt machine models come with a fine-mesh strainer included, which really helps and saves the mess of makeshift strainers like cheesecloth and colanders. If you love Greek-style yoghurt, it’s worth getting a kit that includes one.
Making Dairy-Free Yogurt
Being able to make dairy-free yogurt is a big plus if you’re lactose intolerant, allergic, or follow a vegan diet. Making yoghurt from soy, almond, coconut, or oat milk can be trickier than dairy, as their protein and fat profiles differ. A machine with adjustable temperature control is highly recommended since it allows you to find the ideal conditions for your particular non-dairy milk and starter. Some manufacturers even provide recipes or instructions for dairy-free yogurt, which shows a versatile machine.
Kitchen Footprint: Size and Storage Considerations
Before purchasing, think about where your new electric yogurt maker will live. Measure your available counter space and cupboard height. These appliances come in various sizes, from tall, cylindrical shapes to shorter, wider rectangular models.
If space is tight, a compact model is essential. Also, keep in mind cord length and socket locations. A well-designed homemade yogurt appliance won’t take up too much room or dominate your kitchen workspace.
Energy Consumption and Running Costs
For practical British buyers, running costs matter. The good news is that an electric yogurt maker is very energy-efficient. It uses low wattage, similar to a small light bulb, because it only needs to maintain a gentle warmth, not generate intense heat.
The cost of running an 8-hour cycle is just a few pence. Compared to buying individual pots of premium organic or Greek yoghurt, the automatic yogurt machine quickly pays for itself. The long-term savings are one of the main reasons it’s worth investing in one.
Build Quality, Warranty, and Brand Reputation
A reliable appliance is one built to last. Check the materials used in the main unit. Stainless steel casing is usually more durable and easier to clean than plastic. Notice the lid’s sturdiness and how responsive the buttons are.
A manufacturer’s warranty gives insight into their confidence in the product. One year is standard, but some top brands offer two or three years. Also, take time to research the brand. Established names with a history in kitchen appliances and good customer reviews tend to be safer bets than lesser-known brands.
Price vs. Value: Finding the Sweet Spot for Your Budget
An electric yogurt maker can vary greatly in price, from about £20 for a basic model to over £100 for a multifunctional, feature-packed machine.
- Budget Models (£20-£40): Usually fixed temperature, simple on/off switches, and often plastic containers. Good for beginners wanting to try making basic yoghurt.
- Mid-Range Models (£40-£70): The sweet spot for most buyers. They offer digital timers, adjustable temperature, automatic shut-off, and quality glass fermentation jars. A great balance of features and value.
- Premium Models (£70+): Expect stainless steel build, advanced programming, cooling functions, and included accessories like Greek yoghurt strainers. Great for serious yoghurt makers or those wanting maximum versatility.
Remember, the aim is to find the best value for your needs. The most expensive homemade yogurt appliance isn’t always the best if you don’t use all its features. Conversely, missing key functions like a timer can lead to frustration later.
Conclusion
In the end, choosing the best electric yogurt maker is a personal decision, but it becomes easy with the right information. By focusing on what matters most—whether batch size, precise temperature control for perfect probiotics, or the ability to make dairy-free yogurt—you can pick an appliance that will serve you well for years. The initial cost is soon outweighed by long-term savings and the joy of crafting your own healthy, delicious yoghurt.
More than a gadget, a homemade yogurt appliance is an investment in your health, your wallet, and your creativity in the kitchen. It gives you full control over ingredients, avoiding unwanted sugars, preservatives, and artificial thickeners. We hope this complete guide has helped you understand your options and choose the perfect automatic yogurt machine to start your homemade yoghurt journey. Happy fermenting!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ’s)
1. Can you make Greek yogurt in any electric yogurt maker?
Yes, you can make Greek yoghurt using any electric yogurt maker, but some models make the process much easier. To make Greek yoghurt, first prepare regular yoghurt in your machine. Once fermentation is complete, you need to strain the yoghurt to remove the liquid whey. Some premium models include a fine-mesh strainer designed specifically for this, which simplifies the job a lot. If your machine doesn’t have one, you can strain the yoghurt manually by placing a sieve lined with cheesecloth or a couple of coffee filters over a bowl in the fridge for a few hours.
2. Is it cheaper to make your own yogurt with an automatic yogurt machine?
Definitely. Cost savings are one of the biggest advantages of owning a homemade yogurt appliance. A litre of milk and a spoonful of starter culture (which can be from your previous batch or a small pot of live yoghurt) costs far less than buying a litre of ready-made yoghurt, especially if you buy organic or fancy Greek styles. Electricity to run an 8-12 hour cycle is minimal—a few pence at most. Over a year, a yoghurt-loving family can save a significant amount on groceries, making the machine pay for itself quickly.
3. What kind of milk is best for a homemade yogurt appliance?
The great thing about an electric yogurt maker is its versatility with different milks. For the creamiest, thickest dairy yoghurt, whole milk is best due to its fat content. Semi-skimmed also works well for a slightly lighter yoghurt. Skimmed can be used but tends to produce thinner yoghurt unless you add thickener like milk powder. UHT (long-life) milk is convenient as it doesn’t usually need pre-heating. For dairy-free yoghurt, soy milk generally yields the thickest results, but almond, coconut, and oat milks are popular too. They often need special non-dairy starter cultures and a machine with temperature control.
4. Do I need to buy a special starter culture every time?
No, you don’t. For your very first batch, you will need a starter. This might be a small sachet of freeze-dried yogurt culture bought online or, more simply, a few tablespoons of good-quality plain live yoghurt from the shop (check the label for ‘live active cultures’). The beauty of homemade yoghurt is that after your first batch, you can use a few tablespoons from your fresh batch as the starter for the next one. This method, called ‘backslopping’, can be repeated many times, making it cost-effective. It’s generally recommended to add a fresh starter culture every month or two to keep the probiotics potent.
5. How do I clean my electric yogurt maker and fermentation jars?
Cleaning properly is essential for successful yoghurt making. Never immerse the main unit in water. Just unplug and wipe the inside and outside with a damp cloth. The containers need the most attention. Most modern models have lids and fermentation jars (glass or plastic) that are dishwasher-safe, which is the easiest method. If washing by hand, use hot soapy water and rinse thoroughly to remove residue. It’s crucial that containers are spotless before starting a new batch to prevent unwanted bacteria contaminating your yoghurt.
Informative video
Last update on 2025-12-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
This product presentation was made with AAWP plugin.
